Hi everyone.
I would like to suggest we meet to discuss this. I agree with others that it is an attractive proposal, the issues I would like a face to face discussion on include:
1. We set a deadline of February 2018. I recall being advised we had to do this in order to attract funding from various sources.
2. I don’t know where Leo got that we are continuing to receive submissions for panels? We just published a jam-packed agenda and our call for proposals of a year ago I am certain made it to him and others on his list.
3. We have a practical problem that I don’t think should be decide by e-mail. We have a proposal for a 10 person panel which will need at least 90 to 120 minutes. At this juncture there is no space in our agenda, which is already pretty full.
4. I propose we have a meeting and that we have a published agenda in advance.
Lastly, while this is an attractive proposal I expect it won’t be the last in terms of last minute suggestions. We need to discuss how we deal with these given the commitments we have made to dozens of folks who took the time to apply by our deadline. Again, I like the content of the Panitch proposal but I think given the 2.5 years we have donated to pulling this conference together that we not just say ok and leave the details to be worked out later.
Paul
From: 1919-conference-bounces@lists.umanitoba.ca [mailto:1919-conference-bounces@lists.umanitoba.ca] On Behalf Of Julie Guard Sent: Wednesday, January 16, 2019 2:31 PM To: 1919 conference organizing committee 1919-conference@lists.umanitoba.ca Subject: Re: [1919-Conference] proposal for panel
Hi Paul: I understand your confusion. Our deadline of February 2018 was unusually early, and either Leo assumed we had made a mistake on the date or is pretending he thought that. As it happens, in reality, we had no firm deadline. We continue to accept proposals as they arrive. julie
From: 1919-conference-bounces@lists.umanitoba.camailto:1919-conference-bounces@lists.umanitoba.ca [mailto:1919-conference-bounces@lists.umanitoba.ca] On Behalf Of Paul Moist Sent: Wednesday, January 16, 2019 2:06 PM To: 1919 conference organizing committee Subject: Re: [1919-Conference] proposal for panel
Jim, is his comment correct that we have a February 2019 deadline for panel submissions? I thought the deadline was February 2018??
Paul
From: 1919-conference-bounces@lists.umanitoba.camailto:1919-conference-bounces@lists.umanitoba.ca [mailto:1919-conference-bounces@lists.umanitoba.ca] On Behalf Of James Naylor Sent: Wednesday, January 16, 2019 12:37 PM To: 1919 conference organizing committee <1919-conference@lists.umanitoba.camailto:1919-conference@lists.umanitoba.ca> Subject: [1919-Conference] FW: proposal for panel Importance: High
From: Brandon University 1919strikeconference Sent: Wednesday, January 16, 2019 12:34 PM To: '1919 conference organizing committee' <1919-conference@lists.umanitoba.camailto:1919-conference@lists.umanitoba.ca> Subject: FW: proposal for panel Importance: High
Hi everyone,
Well, here’s something out of the blue!!!
It is, of course, annoying getting this now. But I do have to say, it’s attractive. Indeed, it’s the type of thing that I had hoped to solicit from the beginning but didn’t know how. It would also be a very big draw for Winnipeggers. I await your comments. We should try to discuss this, as much as possible, on the listserv rather than wait until our Feb. 9 meeting to address it.
Jim
James Naylor Professor Department of History Brandon University 270 18th Street Brandon, MB R7A 6A9 Canada
Office: 204 727 9664 Cell: 204 720 2117
Naylor@BrandonU.camailto:Naylor@BrandonU.ca people.brandonu.ca/naylorj/https://people.brandonu.ca/naylorj/
[cid:image001.png@01D1CCA7.E31D2D80]
From: Leo Panitch <lvpanitch@gmail.commailto:lvpanitch@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, January 15, 2019 10:39 PM To: Brandon University 1919strikeconference <1919strikeconference@BrandonU.CAmailto:1919strikeconference@BrandonU.CA> Cc: Meyer Brownstone <meyerb@look.camailto:meyerb@look.ca>; Greg Albo <albo@yorku.camailto:albo@yorku.ca>; Lawrie Cherniack <cherns@mts.netmailto:cherns@mts.net>; Cy Gonick <gonick@cc.umanitoba.camailto:gonick@cc.umanitoba.ca>; Sam Gindin <sam.gindin@gmail.commailto:sam.gindin@gmail.com>; Melanie Panitch <mpanitch@ryerson.camailto:mpanitch@ryerson.ca>; Jim Silver <j.silver@uwinnipeg.camailto:j.silver@uwinnipeg.ca>; gail singer <zingerfilm@sympatico.camailto:zingerfilm@sympatico.ca>; Donald Swartz <Donald_Swartz@carleton.camailto:Donald_Swartz@carleton.ca>; lvp >> Leo Panitch <LVPanitch@gmail.commailto:LVPanitch@gmail.com> Subject: proposal for panel
Dear James Naylor,
A rather large group of us have consulted and would all very much like to come to the conference, for which are proposing the following panel. It would be in the format of a round table with each participants addressing the theme outlined below with an opening 5 minute statement followed by discussion.
The Legacy
What was the legacy the 1919 strike in terms of the political culture it spawned for those who grew up in the following decades? Winnipegers and ex-Winnipegers who were born and grew up there in diverse circumstances and different parts of the city from the 20 to 60s (some of whom still live there, some long since in exile) will discuss what propelled them - through their various experiences with the contradictory class, institutional and cultural nature of that legacy (including not only that of the ILPers, CCFers, CPCers or the labour movement but also the specific ethnic and gendered dimensions of that political culture) - into doing the various kinds of work they subsequently engaged in so as to try to build on but also get beyond those limits and contradictions.
Participants:
Greg Albo, political economist, York University, co-editor The Socialist Register, co-author of In and Out of Crisis: The Financial meltdown and Left Alternatives
Meyer Brownstone, former Deputy Minister, Saskatchewan CCF/NDP governments, emeritus professor University of Toronto, Chair Emeritus Oxfam Canada
Lawrie Cherniak, former Winnipeg city councillor, lawyer, yiddish oral historian, author of Rebel without a Pause
Cy Gonick, founder and editor of Canadian Dimension, emeritus professor University of Manitoba, author of Canada Since 1960: A People's History
Sam Gindin, former Research Director CAW, co-author of The Making of Global Capitalism and The Socialist Challenge Today
Melanie Panitch, School of Disability Studies, Office of Social Innovation, Ryerson University, author, Disability. Mothers and Organization: Accidental Activists
Jim Silver, Urban & Inner-City Studies, Merchants Hotel Campus, University of Winnipeg, co-author of Indians Wear Red: Colonialism, Resistance and Aboriginal Street Gangs Gail Singer, Filmmaker, True Confections, first feature film on growing up in Winnipeg; documentary You Can't Beat a Woman on the culture of violence screened PBS and CBC
Donald Swartz, emeritus professor Carleton University, co-founder Ottawa Committee for Labour Action, co-author of From Consent to Coercion:The Assault on Trade Union Freedoms
Chair, Leo Panitch, emeritus professor York University, co-editor The Socialist Register, author of Crisis of Working Class Politics and Renewing Socialism
We hope you will be as excited about this as we are. We really appreciated the online deadline of early February for panel submissions which made it possible to take the time to get a group like this on board. We see the panel's importance not only in terms of discussing the limited "diversity" of Anglo, Italian and Jewish communities in a radical political culture from which indigenous people were largely excluded or at least marginalized, but also the contradictions of growing up with prominent labour leaders (e.g. Donald Swartz, the grandson of John Blumberg) as well as the contradictory experiences with disability and gender discrimination in the context of a working class, trade union and socialist culture that could be positively built on yet also needed to be transcended.
Looking forward to hearing from you. I will be happy to take on the responsibility of making sure everyone gets registered in good time. Since you already have a draft program up so much ahead of that deadline, I hope you will to be able to indicate, especially for those of us having to make flight arrangements, when this session would be slotted into the program.
Thanks so much for taking on the hard work of organizing this terrific conference.
Best regards, Leo Panitch
